Put all the ingredients into the bowl of a stand mixer and beat on medium until the cheese softens up a bit and the pimentos mash in--about 3 minutes. Combine Cheddar cheese, pimento peppers, and green onions in a medium bowl. Sharp cheddar was enough if you ask me. It appears at every baby shower, wedding and graduation event year round and proudly stands next to the peanut butter and syrup sandwiches–ready to be devoured. That was a high falutin cheese back then, and this was a lowbrow recipe. If there’s nothing else I’ve learned, it’s that homemade pimento cheese doesn’t need a lot of fancy ingredients. The non cream cheese version also melts amazingly well in a grilled cheese sandwich. Real, whole foods belong in your kitchen and in your body. You can also blend this mixture by hand with a mixer or stir it vigorously with a wooden spoon. Thank you! Best stuff ever. Mom was determined not to raise lazy bums for children. Cover and chill for at least 1 hour. Enjoy. That was a high falutin cheese back then, and this was a lowbrow recipe. Get ready to be shocked: they taste like a mild bell pepper. You saved Pimento Cheese without Cream Cheese to your. I don't really love the taste of cream cheese so finding a recipe where there wasn't any was key. Pimento and Bacon Individual Cheese Balls Stacy's Snacks. My great grandmother’s recipe from the 30s-50s era also does not use cream cheese. Stir mayonnaise mixture gently into the cheese mixture using a rubber spatula until thoroughly combined. Your email address will not be published. I started out testing variations of others I found online and I came up with one glaring issue: cream cheese does not belong in homemade pimento cheese. Thank you for sharing this recipe. FREE EMAIL BONUSComfort food for real life. This search takes into account your taste preferences. I like plain Jane like to cheese. Crispy, hot foods are just minutes away—but only if you avoid these air fryer mistakes. Beat the cream cheese at medium speed with an electric mixer until creamy; add Cheddar cheese and continue beating until light and fluffy. So with some more studying and trial and error, we’re there. Beat in mayonnaise and garlic powder; stir in pimento. First time making, tired of the high prices at the store. I remember the dry mustard. If you are following a medically restrictive diet, please consult your doctor or registered dietitian before preparing this recipe for personal consumption. I was looking for a recipe for Thanksgiving, and all of them had cream cheese, which sounded wrong. Thanks. As an Amazon affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Your daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs. Info. We should take note. Jams, preserves, pickles and more! Learn how quick and simple it is to make! It’s easier to get the texture you need that way. 72.4 calories; protein 2.5g 5% DV; carbohydrates 0.6g; fat 6.8g 10% DV; cholesterol 11.6mg 4% DV; sodium 126.4mg 5% DV. this link is to an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines. ®/™©2020 Yummly. But most of us rarely venture in to the world of making their own homemade pimento cheese–after all–the stuff at the store is good. I’d bet money that Mimi’s pimento cheese was made with cream cheese. This recipe was really flavorful and spicy and rivaled the pimento cheese I've had in restaurants. Add comma separated list of ingredients to include in recipe. Required fields are marked *. You’ll need two 4-ounce jars for my recipe. It holds up well as a sandwich and looks much prettier too! That’s all. Nutrient information is not available for all ingredients. Whole truckloads in fact that we broke our backs picking and then hauled them to a dump truck in some farmer’s driveway where they were transported to the factory for processing and canning. But it did not have cream cheese, so it’s not going into mine! I think colby is a great choice for this spread. © Copyright 2020, 15 Chicken Thigh Recipes for the Instant Pot, 15 Quick and Easy Breakfast Casseroles for Busy Mornings, 20 Easy and Flavorful Lunches Perfect for Work-from-Home Days, 15 Easy One-Dish Dinners for Busy Fall Evenings, 12 Watermelon Appetizers Perfect for Summertime, 12 Favorite Fall Breads Made Without a Pumpkin in Sight, 15 Irresistible Fall Cheesecakes You'll Absolutely Fall for, 40 Coffee Shop Drinks and Treats You Can Make at Home, How to Keep Bagged Salad Fresh As Long As Possible, 11 Most Popular Copycat Soups to Make at Home, 15 Filling Family Dinners That Won't Break the Bank, 7 Mistakes You're Probably Making With Your Air Fryer, 15 Best Mexican Recipes for the Air Fryer, Nutrition